Which sentence uses the correct tense?
答案解析
**Core Concept:** Past perfect tense (Grammar).
**Analysis:** 'By the time + past event' requires the past perfect tense (had + past participle) for the earlier action.
**Key Point:** Only A uses 'had left' correctly.
**Error Check:** B uses simple past, C/D mix present tenses with past context.
正确答案:A